TrueNorthFiduciary Risk Advisors
Service · Pharmacy Benefits

Pharmacy contracts with pass-through pricing, full rebate transparency, and no spread.

We restructure or replace your PBM contract to require acquisition-cost pricing, 100% rebate pass-through, audit rights, and contractually defined definitions — closing the three loopholes that let traditional PBMs convert your formulary into a margin product.

Scope

Pharmacy benefits, end-to-end, on a transparent contract.

Pharmacy is the single category where carrier-side margin is most opaque. We focus narrowly on contract structure, formulary governance, and the audit rights that make those terms enforceable.

In scope

  • PBM RFP to transparent and traditional carriers, on identical specifications
  • Contract language: acquisition-cost pricing, MAC list audit rights, rebate pass-through with defined trigger
  • Formulary governance review with clinical pharmacist input
  • Specialty drug carve-out evaluation
  • Quarterly rebate reconciliation against contract
  • Annual pharmacy audit coordination with independent auditor

Out of scope

  • Clinical prior-authorization adjudication (PBM operational)
  • Direct member outreach (left to PBM call center)
  • Drug manufacturer rebate negotiation (PBM holds the GPO contract)
Methodology

How we operate — step by step, in writing.

  1. 01

    Acquisition-cost pricing

    We replace AWP-minus pricing with NADAC- or invoice-based acquisition-cost pricing where available. AWP is a published list price that the pharmacy never pays; pricing off it is a margin construct, not a cost construct.

  2. 02

    Rebate pass-through with defined trigger

    The PBM contract specifies 100% rebate pass-through to the plan, with reconciliation timelines (90 days from receipt), audit rights (30 business days, on-site), and a recoupment formula if reconciliation is late. The contract defines 'rebate' inclusively to capture admin fees, GPO fees, and inflation rebates.

  3. 03

    MAC list and spread audit rights

    Maximum Allowable Cost lists are the PBM's primary spread instrument. We contractually require the right to audit the MAC list, compare it to NADAC, and recoup overpayments. Spread pricing is prohibited by contract — not by good faith.

  4. 04

    Specialty drug strategy

    Specialty drugs are 2% of scripts and 50%+ of pharmacy spend. We evaluate carve-out to a specialty-only vendor, copay-assistance program coordination, and site-of-care steering where clinically appropriate. Patient access is the constraint.

Deliverable schedule

What lands on the committee table, and when.

DeliverableCadenceDetail
  • PBM Contract DiagnosticOn engagementTerm-by-term audit of the current contract against the TrueNorth model contract; gap report.
  • PBM RFP and Award RecommendationOnce per contract cyclePricing comparison on identical specifications, with redline of contract language.
  • Quarterly Rebate ReconciliationQuarterlyRebate by drug class, vs. contract expectation; variance investigation if greater than 5%.
  • Annual Pharmacy Audit CoordinationAnnuallyIndependent pharmacy auditor selected by TrueNorth; report delivered to the plan committee.
Fee structure
PEPM (Per-Employee-Per-Month)$4.50 – $9.00 PEPM

Quoted in writing in Schedule A. Includes contract diagnostic, RFP, and rebate reconciliation. Zero PBM-paid compensation.

The corresponding 408(b)(2) compensation disclosure is published at /legal/408b2 and refreshed quarterly.

The next step is a fiduciary audit, scoped to pharmacy benefits.

Two minutes to scope the engagement. One business day to a calendared 30-minute call with a principal. No carrier in the room. Engagement letter follows in writing.